For the Very First Time

Corin Nemec Michael

Cheryl Pollak Mary Margaret

Mädchen Amick Rhonda

Rebecca Cross Roxy

Tim Griffin

Kenny Johnston John

Donovan Leitch

Gerardo Mejía Cassanova

David Sheinkopf Goldstein

Deidre Hall Mrs. O'Neil

Ernie Lively Mr. O'Neil

Cristine Rose Mrs. Allen

Joe Spano Mr. Allen

David Hayward Coach Hudson

Christian Hoff Steven

Casey Sander Buddy

J.P. Hubbell Luke

Rick Podell Mr. Goldstein

John Ingle Father Talbot

Scott Curtis Matthew